Cultivating allies, engaging with critics and working to change minds: Bacta’s Director of Communications Allaster Gair reflects on the Labour Party Conference

Cultivating allies, engaging with critics and working to change minds: Bacta’s Director of Communications Allaster Gair reflects on the Labour Party Conference

Allaster Gair reflects on the Labour Party Conference

How was Bacta received at Conference?

Very well: we had a lot of positive, productive conversations with MPs and Ministers about the contribution Bacta members make to their constituencies and the challenges ahead.

It was also valuable to catch up with stakeholders from across the industry and engage with people who might not necessarily like our sector. In some cases, we were able to change minds; in others, we agreed to disagree. Keeping that dialogue open matters. We need to be willing to engage with those who challenge us as well as those who already support us.

Do you think there’s an appetite to seemingly punish the land-based industry, as the narrative might suggest?

I don’t think there is an appetite across the Labour Party to punish the land-based industry. There are certainly individual MPs and groups whose opposition to gambling amounts to a prohibitionist position, but that wasn’t representative of the conversations we had.

Our challenge is to ensure that pragmatic MPs who understand our contribution are heard. Our members support jobs directly and through the supply chain, sustain high streets and contribute to coastal communities across the country. MPs don’t have to enjoy gambling themselves to recognise that millions of their constituents do, and that those people should have access to safe, regulated venues.

The Daily Express ran with a story that the Party is divided over the PM’s policy on raising MGD – do you concur?

I wouldn’t necessarily characterise it as a divided party. There are different views, as you would expect on an issue like this. But our position is that the economic evidence makes an overwhelming case against increasing MGD.

The evidence we have presented shows that an increase would axe jobs, drive closures and damage seaside communities and high streets, while undermining the overall tax take. If the fiscal case does not stand up, the decision becomes a political one, and politicians will inevitably take different positions. We are asking them to follow the overwhelming evidence.

Where are the pockets of support within the Labour Party – MPs in seaside constituencies, for example?

Absolutely, seaside MPs are an important source of support because they see the contribution our members make to tourism, employment and their local economies. But that support extends well beyond the coast.

We also met MPs representing constituencies that wouldn’t necessarily fit the traditional picture of our sector. They understand that gambling is a pastime enjoyed by millions and that safe, regulated venues have an important role.

The recent raids on illegal gambling premises also underline the need to take the land-based black market seriously. Removing legitimate venues does not remove demand. It risks pushing customers towards operators with none of the protections or oversight required of our members.

Is the PM’s focus on AGCs politically motivated or fiscally driven?

In our view, it is politically motivated. We do not believe the fiscal evidence supports an increase in MGD, and those arguments will need to be worked through between the Treasury and Number 10 ahead of the Budget.

The Prime Minister’s focus has been on restricting what he sees as the growth of AGCs on high streets. The proposed removal of “aim to permit” has been the political vehicle for that. We would argue that the Government has already acted in this space. 

Restricting growth and taxing existing businesses out of viability are very different propositions. We have not heard the Prime Minister advocate the latter, and we would expect the Government to recognise the consequences and take a proportionate approach.

What have the take-outs been from being in Liverpool?

For Bacta, the positive engagement was encouraging. We had useful conversations, challenged assumptions and have plenty to follow up on.

My wider impression was of a party in something of a holding pattern. There was plenty of noise and a number of announcements, but much of the discussion seemed directed towards the next election rather than what can be delivered now.

Labour has a substantial majority and the ability to govern, yet it sometimes feels constrained by the commitments of its previous manifesto. That tension was an interesting feature of the conference: a new Prime Minister setting out his direction while governing within an existing mandate.

If the Burnham bounce continues and Labour convincingly wins the Holborn and St Pancras by-election on 8 October, do you think they will capitalise on the momentum and call a snap general election? What is the Conference mood music on this? Will Burnham do what Brown failed to do and go early?

A snap election is always a possibility. Other parties will be preparing for that, and Bacta needs to be prepared too.

However, there are reasons for caution. Many Labour MPs would feel that their seats were at risk, which would create pressure against an early election. Burnham has also only been Prime Minister for a matter of weeks. He needs to demonstrate progress and give voters a reason to endorse his Government.

My overwhelming impression from conference was that things may get tougher before they get better. I didn’t come away feeling there was yet the confidence or optimism that would make an early election an obvious opportunity. A strong by-election result could influence the calculation, but it would not settle it.

 

Allaster Gair reflects on the Labour Party Conference

How was Bacta received at Conference?

Very well: we had a lot of positive, productive conversations with MPs and Ministers about the contribution Bacta members make to their constituencies and the challenges ahead.

It was also valuable to catch up with stakeholders from across the industry and engage with people who might not necessarily like our sector. In some cases, we were able to change minds; in others, we agreed to disagree. Keeping that dialogue open matters. We need to be willing to engage with those who challenge us as well as those who already support us.

Do you think there’s an appetite to seemingly punish the land-based industry, as the narrative might suggest?

I don’t think there is an appetite across the Labour Party to punish the land-based industry. There are certainly individual MPs and groups whose opposition to gambling amounts to a prohibitionist position, but that wasn’t representative of the conversations we had.

Our challenge is to ensure that pragmatic MPs who understand our contribution are heard. Our members support jobs directly and through the supply chain, sustain high streets and contribute to coastal communities across the country. MPs don’t have to enjoy gambling themselves to recognise that millions of their constituents do, and that those people should have access to safe, regulated venues.

The Daily Express ran with a story that the Party is divided over the PM’s policy on raising MGD – do you concur?

I wouldn’t necessarily characterise it as a divided party. There are different views, as you would expect on an issue like this. But our position is that the economic evidence makes an overwhelming case against increasing MGD.

The evidence we have presented shows that an increase would axe jobs, drive closures and damage seaside communities and high streets, while undermining the overall tax take. If the fiscal case does not stand up, the decision becomes a political one, and politicians will inevitably take different positions. We are asking them to follow the overwhelming evidence.

Where are the pockets of support within the Labour Party – MPs in seaside constituencies, for example?

Absolutely, seaside MPs are an important source of support because they see the contribution our members make to tourism, employment and their local economies. But that support extends well beyond the coast.

We also met MPs representing constituencies that wouldn’t necessarily fit the traditional picture of our sector. They understand that gambling is a pastime enjoyed by millions and that safe, regulated venues have an important role.

The recent raids on illegal gambling premises also underline the need to take the land-based black market seriously. Removing legitimate venues does not remove demand. It risks pushing customers towards operators with none of the protections or oversight required of our members.

Is the PM’s focus on AGCs politically motivated or fiscally driven?

In our view, it is politically motivated. We do not believe the fiscal evidence supports an increase in MGD, and those arguments will need to be worked through between the Treasury and Number 10 ahead of the Budget.

The Prime Minister’s focus has been on restricting what he sees as the growth of AGCs on high streets. The proposed removal of “aim to permit” has been the political vehicle for that. We would argue that the Government has already acted in this space. 

Restricting growth and taxing existing businesses out of viability are very different propositions. We have not heard the Prime Minister advocate the latter, and we would expect the Government to recognise the consequences and take a proportionate approach.

What have the take-outs been from being in Liverpool?

For Bacta, the positive engagement was encouraging. We had useful conversations, challenged assumptions and have plenty to follow up on.

My wider impression was of a party in something of a holding pattern. There was plenty of noise and a number of announcements, but much of the discussion seemed directed towards the next election rather than what can be delivered now.

Labour has a substantial majority and the ability to govern, yet it sometimes feels constrained by the commitments of its previous manifesto. That tension was an interesting feature of the conference: a new Prime Minister setting out his direction while governing within an existing mandate.

If the Burnham bounce continues and Labour convincingly wins the Holborn and St Pancras by-election on 8 October, do you think they will capitalise on the momentum and call a snap general election? What is the Conference mood music on this? Will Burnham do what Brown failed to do and go early?

A snap election is always a possibility. Other parties will be preparing for that, and Bacta needs to be prepared too.

However, there are reasons for caution. Many Labour MPs would feel that their seats were at risk, which would create pressure against an early election. Burnham has also only been Prime Minister for a matter of weeks. He needs to demonstrate progress and give voters a reason to endorse his Government.

My overwhelming impression from conference was that things may get tougher before they get better. I didn’t come away feeling there was yet the confidence or optimism that would make an early election an obvious opportunity. A strong by-election result could influence the calculation, but it would not settle it.